‘When Virat Kohli Was Captain They Used to Score Big’: Gambhir’s Strategy Under Fire After India’s Stunning Loss to South Africa

India’s shock 30-run defeat to South Africa at the Eden Gardens has triggered a wave of criticism directed at head coach Gautam Gambhir, with several former cricketers asserting that the current team is leaving far too much to chance on highly unpredictable pitches.

The loss, which saw India fall short of a modest 124-run target — the lowest they have ever failed to chase at home in Test cricket — has raised serious concerns about the side’s batting temperament and tactical preparation. The pitch, which heavily favoured spin from the opening session, became the centre of discussion as India’s batting line-up crumbled under consistent pressure from the South African attack.

Among the voices questioning India’s approach was a former IPL teammate who remarked that “when Virat Kohli was captain, they used to score big even on challenging surfaces.” The comment reflects a growing sentiment that India, once known for mastering difficult conditions under Kohli’s leadership, are now overly dependent on pitch conditions rather than skill execution.

South African pace legend Shaun Pollock also criticised India’s batting mindset, stating that the side looked “nervous and confused” while facing disciplined South African bowling. He suggested that India’s hesitation to apply basic Test-match discipline played a bigger role in the defeat than the nature of the wicket.

Adding to the criticism, former Australia wicketkeeper Brad Haddin argued that this was not the first time India’s plan to use rank turners had backfired under Gambhir’s guidance. Haddin recalled a similar situation in which India’s batters succumbed to excessive turn instead of adapting to conditions. He emphasised that relying on extreme pitches could be a risky long-term strategy, especially against well-prepared opposition teams.

Gambhir, however, defended the decision to request such a surface, pointing the blame entirely at India’s poor shot selection. He insisted that the pitch was challenging but not unplayable, adding that the team must take responsibility for failing to execute their plans.

With major series ahead and expectations soaring after Gambhir’s appointment as head coach, India’s latest defeat has opened up significant debate on approach, adaptability, and strategic clarity. As scrutiny grows, the focus will be on how Gambhir and his team recalibrate their methods before the next challenge.